For Sale
For Sale
For Sale
For Sale
For Sale
For Sale
Request an appointment
Recommend Mobile Jay
Request an appointment See phone Send email
Follow me
Facebooktwitter

Client Experience Ratings

Rating system for real estate agents and criteria - Learn more
393 Surveys

Pittsford DR

Surveyed on Apr 17, 2026
Represented the Seller
Represented the Seller
5/5
Start FullStart FullStart FullStart FullStart Full
Competency
5/5
Knowledge
5/5
Communication
5/5
Experience
5/5

Seller's Comment

Steven P
Posted on Apr 17, 2026

“Smooth transaction from start to finish. Wonderful experience ”

Agent's Comment

Jay Thieme
Posted on Apr 17, 2026
Thank you for great review. I was grateful for the opportunity to work with you.

Mallard Run CT

Surveyed on Apr 1, 2026
Represented the Buyer
Represented the Buyer
5/5
Start FullStart FullStart FullStart FullStart Full
Competency
5/5
Knowledge
5/5
Communication
5/5
Experience
5/5

Buyer's Comment

Rebecca W
Posted on Apr 1, 2026

“Our realtor was also representing the sellers also. Jay stepped in to help us. He took such great care of us I can t say enough nice things about him? I highly recommend him ”

Agent's Comment

Jay Thieme
Posted on Apr 01, 2026
Thank you Rebecca. It's an incredible home. Congratulations on the purchase. Wishing y'all nothing but the best.

Breezeway Bend LN

Surveyed on Jan 19, 2026
Represented the Seller
Represented the Seller
5/5
Start FullStart FullStart FullStart FullStart Full
Competency
5/5
Knowledge
5/5
Communication
5/5
Experience
5/5

Seller's Comment

Jeffrey T
Posted on Jan 19, 2026

“This is our fifth buying or selling real estate transaction that we have entrusted Jay with. It went as smoothly as the prior four transactions. Jay knows the market, has invaluable experience from closing hundreds of transactions, is timely and open in his inactions with his clients, and explains the process along the way. We will use Jay again in the future and highly recommend him to whomever is searching for a real estate professional.”

Agent's Comment

Jay Thieme
Posted on Jan 19, 2026
Thank you for the awesome review and your trust over the years.

Middleoak Grove LN

Surveyed 4 months ago
Represented the Seller
Represented the Seller
5/5
Start FullStart FullStart FullStart FullStart Full
Competency
5/5
Knowledge
5/5
Communication
5/5
Experience
5/5

Seller's Comment

Erik H
Posted on Dec 10, 2025

“Great real estate agent and selling experience. ”

Agent's Comment

Jay Thieme
Posted on Dec 10, 2025
Thank you for the 5 star review and your trust in helping with y'all's move to Central Texas.

Guthrie Ridge LN

Surveyed 4 months ago
Represented the Seller
Represented the Seller
5/5
Start FullStart FullStart FullStart FullStart Full
Competency
5/5
Knowledge
5/5
Communication
5/5
Experience
5/5

Seller's Comment

Dave S
Posted on Dec 7, 2025

“Best realtor ever Thanks Jay for working with us to prepare, market, and close on our house, it was a pleasure working with you. ”

Agent's Comment

Jay Thieme
Posted on Dec 07, 2025
Thank you so much for the great review. I greatly appreciate your trust and friendship over the years.

Summer Gardens LN

Surveyed 4 months ago
Represented the Seller
Represented the Seller
5/5
Start FullStart FullStart FullStart FullStart Full
Competency
5/5
Knowledge
5/5
Communication
5/5
Experience
5/5

Seller's Comment

Jeryl B
Posted on Dec 7, 2025

“Jay goes above and beyond any reasonable expectation for a real estate agent. If we are ever moving back to the Houston area we will definitely use Jay to help us find a home. ”

Agent's Comment

Jay Thieme
Posted on Dec 07, 2025
Love you guys. Thank you so much for the friendship

Big Fork CT

Surveyed 5 months ago
Represented the Seller
Represented the Seller
5/5
Start FullStart FullStart FullStart FullStart Full
Competency
5/5
Knowledge
5/5
Communication
5/5
Experience
5/5

Seller's Comment

Tab B
Posted on Nov 17, 2025

“Jay was great to work with long distance. He walked us through the current market and maintained constant communication about our property up to and through the sale. Outstanding experience ”

Agent's Comment

Jay Thieme
Posted on Nov 17, 2025
Thank you so much for the awesome review! Wishing nothing but the best for you guys. Stay safe while up in the air.

Grey Sparrow DR

Surveyed 8 months ago
Represented the Seller
Represented the Seller
5/5
Start FullStart FullStart FullStart FullStart Full
Competency
5/5
Knowledge
5/5
Communication
5/5
Experience
5/5

Seller's Comment

Carol O
Posted on Aug 16, 2025

“Jay is and has been awesome ”

Agent's Comment

Jay Thieme
Posted on Aug 16, 2025
Thank you Carol. Wishing nothing but the best for you in Florida.

Sierra Lake CT

Surveyed 8 months ago
Represented the Seller
Represented the Seller
5/5
Start FullStart FullStart FullStart FullStart Full
Competency
5/5
Knowledge
5/5
Communication
5/5
Experience
5/5

Blue Cove CT

Surveyed 8 months ago
Represented the Buyer
Represented the Buyer
5/5
Start FullStart FullStart FullStart FullStart Full
Competency
5/5
Knowledge
5/5
Communication
5/5
Experience
5/5

Lone Tree DR

Surveyed 8 months ago
Represented the Seller
Represented the Seller
5/5
Start FullStart FullStart FullStart FullStart Full
Competency
5/5
Knowledge
5/5
Communication
5/5
Experience
5/5

Seller's Comment

Kevin S
Posted on Aug 7, 2025

“Jay Thieme is the best It s always been a pleasure using him as our Realtor. ”

Agent's Comment

Jay Thieme
Posted on Aug 07, 2025
I've loved working for y'all over the years. I'm very grateful for our friendship.

Sage Glen LN

Surveyed 8 months ago
Represented the Seller
Represented the Seller
5/5
Start FullStart FullStart FullStart FullStart Full
Competency
5/5
Knowledge
5/5
Communication
5/5
Experience
5/5

Agent's Comment

Jay Thieme
Posted on Jul 27, 2025
Thank you so much!!

Tivoli DR

Surveyed 9 months ago
Represented the Seller
Represented the Seller
5/5
Start FullStart FullStart FullStart FullStart Full
Competency
5/5
Knowledge
5/5
Communication
5/5
Experience
5/5

Seller's Comment

Ross
Posted on Jul 2, 2025

“Jay was great at explaining the process and issues that came up during the sale. He always responded quickly when contacted and was a real pleasure to work with through the process. When we asked our former realtor, and friend, to recommend some realtors for this house sale she gave us only one name, Jay Thieme - we were not disappointed ”

Grand Vista LN

Surveyed 9 months ago
Represented the Buyer
Represented the Buyer
5/5
Start FullStart FullStart FullStart FullStart Full
Competency
5/5
Knowledge
5/5
Communication
5/5
Experience
5/5

Agent's Comment

Jay Thieme
Posted on Jun 24, 2025
Thank you very much!!

Spoon Bill ST

Surveyed 10 months ago
Represented the Buyer
Represented the Buyer
5/5
Start FullStart FullStart FullStart FullStart Full
Competency
5/5
Knowledge
5/5
Communication
5/5
Experience
5/5

Buyer's Comment

Kevin S
Posted on Jun 11, 2025

“Great Professional realtor Third time he has helped us purchase a home and he never disappoints. ”

Overall Rating
4.97/5
Rating based on 393 completed surveys.
Start FullStart FullStart FullStart FullStar Half-Quarter
4.96 / 5
Start FullStart FullStart FullStart FullStar Half-Quarter
Competency
4.96 / 5
Start FullStart FullStart FullStart FullStar Half-Quarter
Market Knowledge
4.98 / 5
Start FullStart FullStart FullStart FullStar Half-Quarter
Communication
4.97 / 5
Start FullStart FullStart FullStart FullStar Half-Quarter
Experience